PlanetJune Craft Blog

Latest news and updates from June

Professional Design vs Hobby Design

If you’ve ever considered upgrading your craft/design hobby into a business, this post may offer an interesting insight, as I’m now both a professional designer in one field (crochet) and a hobby designer in another (knitwear), so I can speak to both sides of this.

12 knit sweaters project

My Hobby/Pro Designer Experiences

I’m really enjoying my journey as a knitwear designer – I get to design, make and wear my own clothes, and that feels like a pretty amazing process. Every now and then, I feel a little wistful that I’m not parlaying my designs into a new income stream by selling patterns for my sweaters. It may seem like an obvious next step, but there are many reasons why I don’t want to do this.

Knitting is my hobby. I enjoy doing it for relaxation in between my crochet designs. I like making clothes for myself, that fit me and in colours I’ll wear. I can take months or years to finish a design and it doesn’t matter. If something isn’t perfect I can fudge it to make it good enough to wear.

Crochet is my business. It’s how I earn my living. I enjoy the challenge of developing new designs – and I love the things I design! – but there’s always a voice at the back of my head thinking ‘How well will this translate into a pattern? How can I explain this technique? Can I simplify anything to make it more enjoyable to crochet?’ Every new design has to be as good as I can possibly make it, and, while I never hurry an individual design, there’s always pressure to have regular new pattern releases, to keep PlanetJune in people’s minds and keep my business going.

PlanetJune Accessories 2018 Shawl crochet pattern collection

Support. I’ve built an extensive website full of tutorials to help crocheters successfully follow my patterns. I don’t have the time or inclination to do that for knitting techniques. At best, I could provide links to other sites that offer tutorials, and that’s not the level of service people expect from me.

PlanetJune Crochet Video Tutorials on YouTube

Fitted garments. I intentionally don’t design fitted garments in crochet. When I design and knit clothes for myself, I make them to fit me (short and pear-shaped). There are so many different body types and shapes, and it’s important that your clothes fit your shape as well as your size, or they won’t look or feel good on you. And I love making knitwear for myself that makes me feel good when I wear it!

silver thermal pullover by June Gilbank

If I designed a (knit or crochet) garment in the style I like as a pattern for sale, I’d have to:

  1. design it for ‘standard’ body measurements
  2. make a standard-sized sample (that wouldn’t fit me well!)
  3. find a ‘standard’ shaped lady to model it for the pattern photos
  4. either accept that ‘non-standard’ bodies (i.e. most people!) won’t be 100% happy with the result of my pattern, or offer extensive customization advice for how to modify the sizes to fit your own shape

The other option would be to change my design style to create very simple, non-fitted, rectangle-based garments that will work for most people as-is, but that’s not a style I’d enjoy either making or wearing. (There are also plenty of designs like that already, so I probably wouldn’t even make any money from trying to sell something I didn’t want to make in the first place!)

My Decision

I’m sure there are many more potential difficulties I haven’t even thought of, but just these few are more than enough to keep me from starting down the path of publishing my knitwear designs.

I know I don’t have time to start a parallel second career, and certainly not to run a knitwear pattern business with the level of quality and support that (I hope) people have come to expect from PlanetJune.

So, at least for the foreseeable future, I’m keeping my knitting (and garment design) on a purely hobby level. But I do love sharing what I’ve made, and I hope my projects will inspire others to try knitting (or crocheting, or sewing) a garment. It’s a very empowering feeling to be able to make your own clothes, and so satisfying when you get it right and it actually fits!

12 knit sweaters project

Hobby or Business?

Finding a way to make a profitable business from your hobby may sound like a dream come true, but it has the potential to suck all the joy out of your hobby, and, at best, it permanently changes your relationship with your craft.

I’m endlessly grateful that I’ve been able to build a successful business from my crochet designs. I try to keep innovating and developing new techniques to keep my designs fresh and exciting – both for my customers, and for my own enjoyment and improvement in my craft!

PlanetJune pattern selection

But, even so, I do sometimes miss the freedom of being able to create more complex crocheted art pieces that wouldn’t make a good pattern. Keeping my knitting as a purely creative outlet, with no motive other than making things I want to make, has given me that freedom back. It’s a way to balance the pressure of creating for my business with the joy and relaxation that only comes with making for fun.

WIP cardigans - knit and crocheted - by planetjune

So, the moral of the story is: there’s no right answer as to whether you should try to turn your hobby into a money-making venture:

  • A hobby gives you complete artistic freedom, relaxation, enjoyment, and personal satisfaction.
  • A business reduces all those things in exchange for the possibility of success: happy customers, recognition, more financial freedom, etc.

Having a hobby can give you a release from the stresses of everyday life. Turning it into a business adds to those stresses, but if you’re willing to put in time, hard work, and the determination to keep going even when you don’t feel like it, turning your hobby into a business can be very rewarding.

Or you could keep it more casual – instead of aiming to start a serious business enterprise, you could have a ‘hobby business’, where you sell a few things you’ve made to pay for your craft supplies etc, but don’t try to scale it up into a full-time business.

On the other hand, there’s a lot to be said for the pure joy of making just for fun! Maybe you should keep your craft as a hobby, like my knitting- it’s important to protect the things that make you happy. πŸ™‚


So, what’s your experience? Have you ever considered turning your hobby into a business? Have my words made you think about doing (or not doing!) it? Or have you already tried, and how did that change your relationship with your hobby?

I’d love to know! Please leave your thoughts in the comments below…

6 Comments »

  1. Sheryl said

    I know you are very busy, and my question does not directly apply to your lovely crochet patterns, so if you choose not to reply, I will understand. However, I was pleased to find out from this blog article that you are a knitter, too. My question is (really two questions): which craft (knitting or crochet) do you like best, and which did you learn first? I learned how to crochet first, using your book, which I love. πŸ˜‰ and later learned how to knit. I find that I enjoy knitting more, but I still get a crochet bug periodically when that is what I prefer to do for a little while. I love to hear about how others started with these wonderful yarn crafts! Thank you for your Idiot’s Guide: Crochet book; it’s fabulous!!

    • June said

      Hi Sheryl! I learned to crochet first (see this post for details!) and then taught myself to knit many years later (see this post). I love knitting and crochet for different reasons – as I said above, knitting is just a hobby for me, whereas almost everything I crochet is destined to become a pattern, so it’s hard to say which I like more, as I have to treat them so differently.

      I wouldn’t want to give up either, though! I find the differently constructed stitches (crocheted stitches are essentially loose knots; knitted stitches are single loops) make one craft ideally suited for certain projects more than others. Amigurumi, for example, is perfectly suited to crochet – the ideal fabric is stiff and rigid to hold its shape, and that’s almost impossible to achieve with knitting. Fitted clothing is perfectly suited to knitting – the ideal fabric is stretchy and drapes well to fit the body, and that’s very easy to achieve with knitting. That’s not to say you can’t make good knitted toys or good crocheted clothing, but when you have multiple tools at your disposal, I like to choose the most suitable one for each task!

      I don’t consider crochet to be the inferior cousin to knitting at all. Crocheted lace is easier than knitted lace, you can’t drop multiple stitches in crochet, crocheted projects work up far more quickly. I’ve crocheted a cardigan (see this post) and it’s lovely, and was easy and incredibly fast to complete. With a good design and suitable yarn, you can make either craft work for most projects, so you can do whichever you enjoy! And if you can both knit and crochet, you have the best of both worlds, and you can alternate both crafts to give your hands and wrists a break from the repetitive motions of each without sitting idle. πŸ™‚

  2. Caitlin said

    It’s why when anyone asks if I want to sell the toys I make or the little cross stitches I go NO! I do make little cross stitch patterns and share them on a fairly infrequent basis. But I could never make 20 of the same toy and churn them out in order to have stock. I’m just not interested in that! It is truly a hobby for me. I keep thinking of how to make my patterns make me more money and maybe I can make it work but it would be serious work and I’m not really ready to do that to my hobby as it one of the things keeping me sane.

    • June said

      Thanks so much for sharing this, Caitlyn. Even though I’m making my living from my patterns, I still understand what you mean – I’m sure I could make a lot more money from my patterns if I spent most of my time marketing, advertising, building social media followings, etc, but that would really ruin my enjoyment of everything.

      I’m trying to build a business where I can enjoy my creativity while sharing it with others in a way that can support me financially. I’ve been doing this for 12 years and I’m still trying to find my way along that path – it’s not an easy balance to make money from doing what you love without tainting that love.

  3. Ruth Lister said

    It was great to read of your experience June and I can totally appreciate your reasoning.
    Crochet and sewing are my hobbies and I do both for my extended family. I enjoy doing various projects for them as it has reacquainted me with these skills and I have an interest to do in my spare time now that I’m retired. I would not consider doing either as a business as I do it simply for the enjoyment.
    I took some time out before starting new family projects recently and completed your lovely Christmas Cactus crochet that I started quite some months ago. I’m really happy with the end result though I may have stitched it together a little too tightly. It looks great anyway. Thsnk you. ?

    • June said

      I’m very happy to hear that, Ruth! And making gifts for family and friends who appreciate them is its own reward πŸ™‚

RSS feed for comments on this post

Commenting

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave a comment here! I read and appreciate every comment. I only respond to questions here on the blog, so please return to this page to see my reply, or check the box below to subscribe to new comments by email.

Please note that I can only answer questions related to PlanetJune patterns and tutorials (see details), and I can only respond to questions or comments written in English. Thank you :) - June

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Welcome to PlanetJune!

    June Gilbank

    Hi, I'm June. Welcome to my world of nature-inspired crochet and crafting. I hope you enjoy your visit!

    If you'd like to get in touch, you can contact me here.
    crocheted Canadian flag by PlanetJune
  • Follow me

    RSS FeedSubscribe to my blog by EmailFollow me on TwitterFollow me on Facebook
    Friend me on RavelryWatch me on YouTubeFollow me on PinterestFollow me on Instagram
  • Browse Blog Categories

  • Blog Archives

  • Support PlanetJune!

    Want to say thanks? You can send me money in seconds at paypal.me/planetjune or send me a donation through my shop.

    Or simply click one of these links before you shop at Amazon, and I'll make a small commission on your purchase, at no cost to you:
    • amazon.com
    • amazon.ca
    • amazon.co.uk
    • amazon.de
    Thank you for your support!
Back to top